Jump to content

Episode 625

From NorseCode Wiki
Episode 625

The Day Carson Wentz Became President

Hosts Arif Hasan, James Pogatshnik
Guests
Type Recap

Norse Code Episode 625: The Day Carson Wentz Became President was a game recap episode following the Vikings' Monday Night Football loss to the Buffalo Bills. James described it as a maintenance session made out of obligation rather than love. The episode title was coined in the mailbag when a question about Carson Wentz's power to heal the nation inadvertently led Arif to announce, definitively, that November 9th, 2026 was the day Carson Wentz became president.

Overview

[edit]

Cold Open: The Emergency Quarterback Hypothetical

[edit]

The episode opened with a question originally posed by Kevin Clark — and retweeted by Clark just this week — asking: who is the oldest retired quarterback who could plausibly start a game right now and be better than the worst starting quarterback in football? James and Arif spent considerable pre-show time on the question before Arif decided to offload the cognitive burden onto a machine, specifically in the name of declining as much as the Vikings offence.

The working standard was Drew Brees, whose name had come up in the context of Sean Payton supposedly contemplating him as an emergency starter the previous year. The question was whether the bracket could be extended older. Peyton Manning (now 50) was considered and rejected: his final season was so cooked, Arif argued, that the over-the-middle pass was a duck and the outside throws were worse. Manning was out.

Arif concluded that the answer, before Sumer Brain, was Tom Brady — plausibly capable of outperforming a 25th-ranked NFL quarterback. He then asked Sumer Brain the question. Sumer Brain responded with Matt Ryan and Colt McCoy as candidates (using Justin Herbert, improbably, as the floor), before working through Ryan Tannehill, Russell Wilson (described as very funny), someone named Derikar who was available, Jimmy Garoppolo, and Taylor Heinicke. It concluded that Trevor Siemian and PJ Walker were not answers. When Arif pushed it toward Tom Brady, it confirmed Brady, though its database only contained his 2022 season — making it aware of only one year of Brady's legendary career. It then named Aaron Rodgers as older than Tom Brady, which is incorrect; Arif noted he loved AI.

With Brady confirmed as a reasonable outer limit, the question became whether anyone older qualified. Drew Bledsoe (52) looked extremely fit — winery-owner fit, Arif said, standing in front of a winery that presumably he owned — but not football fit. A second hit would be disastrous. James noted that the number seven jersey would just fall over mysteriously.

James introduced Bernie Kosar, who was six foot three. Arif looked him up. The first headline that came up was "how sick is Bernie Kosar?", shortly followed by confirmation that he had been hospitalised with five procedures including a liver transplant. Kosar was out. The difference between being hurt and being injured, James observed.

The eventual consensus: Vinny Testaverde. He entered the league at approximately six foot three and 232 pounds and, Arif reported, the build had aged extremely well — still visibly enormous. If you are an Italian American, Arif said, that is exactly how you want to age. Testaverde played 21 seasons for a reason. He is their Lord and Saviour.

Vikings vs. Bills: The Game

[edit]

Arif characterised it as an unmitigated offensive disaster. James noted that Joe Buck and Troy Aikman spent the entire broadcast laughing at how bad the Vikings were — suggesting it may have saved their marriage.

Arif watched the Monday Night Football Next Gen Stats broadcast with Dominic Foxworth, Seth Walder, and Brian Hoyer — a production he praised for its depth, breaking down scheme and analytics rather than the main broadcast's colour commentary approach. By the halfway point, even that crew was done. When Wentz threw an interception that was dropped by the Bills defender, Foxworth said instantly: "I'm going to throw something through my screen." The broadcast had broken him.

Franchise Infamy: The Statistical Context

[edit]

Arif compiled performance data going back to 1999 for Vikings quarterbacks (with some data back to 1977 available for a future Wide Left piece). With a minimum of 14 dropbacks, Wentz's performance against the Bills was the third worst EPA per dropback game a Vikings quarterback has had since 1999, opponent-adjusted.

The top of the list:

  1. Geron Hall vs. Green Bay, Week 17, 2023 — the New Year's Eve game; crossed the negative 1.0 EPA per dropback threshold; the minimum 14 dropbacks. Benched almost immediately.
  2. Brad Johnson vs. Chicago, Week 13, 2006 — 28 dropbacks; a stomach-turner.
  3. Carson Wentz vs. Buffalo, 2026 — worse than Matt Cassel vs. Cincinnati (2013 Week 16), worse than Max Brosmer vs. Seattle (Week 13, 2025), worse than any JJ McCarthy game, worse than Randall Cunningham vs. Detroit (1999 Week 6), worse than Christian Ponder vs. Detroit (Week 14, 2011), worse than Dante Culpepper vs. the Giants (2000), worse than Teddy Bridgewater's Week 1, 2015 outing against the 49ers, worse than Cousins vs. Green Bay in Week 16, 2019 (the game where the team discovered that spamming the rollout play-action button the whole season had been the problem), worse than any Spurgeon Wynn game, worse than Sam Darnold vs. Detroit (Week 18), and worse than Bubby Brister vs. the Colts in Week 17, 2000. Both Max Brosmer games appeared on the full list. Many of the entries were Week 16 or Week 17 games featuring third-string quarterbacks; Arif noted there was perhaps a reason for that.

By completion percentage over expected (CPOE, the PFF metric based on throw depth, location, and other factors), Wentz's performance was the worst since at least 2006 at −30.7:

  1. Carson Wentz vs. Buffalo, 2026 (−30.7)
  2. Tarvaris Jackson vs. Dallas, Week 7, 2007 (−22.6; six for sixteen when expected completion percentage was 60%)
  3. (Gap)
  4. Joshua Dobbs, the game against the Raiders in which he was benched

Wentz was under pressure on approximately 44% of dropbacks — high, but not so high as to fully explain the performance.

Arif and James noted that Justin Jefferson deserved better. James drew a contrast with Larry Fitzgerald, who made the Hall of Fame regardless of years of bad quarterback play because he was at least getting catchable balls. Jefferson was not getting balls. He was not getting catchable balls. He was not getting yards. This was his prime. Attributed to either Arif or Luke (they could not recall which): "Any time you can bring back the worst quarterback room in the league, you got to do it. You got to run it back."

Arif offered a political parallel. The Vikings brought in a veteran who had been starting for a while (Biden/Wentz). They held a fake primary in which actual competition was discouraged (Dean Phillips ran, real alternatives were sidelined). Then, on a national stage, it was revealed the veteran did not have it together (Biden's dementia; Murray's concussion). The scramble for a replacement began. The Vikings brought in Kamala Harris. Arif did not remember how that election went. James clarified: bad place. The analogy held.

Defence: A Herculean Performance

[edit]

The Vikings defence was, by any reasonable measure, extraordinary. The Bills had been averaging over 30 points per game and had scored 24 against the Chargers in a game in which they turned the ball over five times. The Vikings held them to 23 — the lowest point total the Bills had given up all season. The defence played 79 snaps. Blitz rate: 79%, described as one of the lower rates of the year. Pressure rate: 50%.

James, who missed the opening minutes due to public address announcing a basketball game, listened to Paul Allen on the drive over and heard him describe the defensive substitutions as happening like hockey line changes — seven Vikings sitting on the sideline, running in all at once for specific third-down snaps.

Tackle totals: Blake Cashman 12 (missed part of the game), Eric Wilson 9, Joshua Metellus 8, James Pierre 6, Dallas Turner 5, Elijah Williams 5, Jalen Redmond 5, Levi Drake Rodriguez 5, Turingur Dawkins 5, Andrew Van Ginkel 4, Byron Murphy 4, Isaiah Rogers 4, Ivan Pace 4, Jacob Thomas 3, Bo Richter 2, Dominique Orange 2, Harrison Smith 2, Kyle Van Noy 2. DJ Dallas, Jake Golday (12 snaps), and Jay Ward (13 snaps) also contributed, likely on special teams. Zamiah Vaughn played three snaps.

Andrew Van Ginkel led the game with seven pressures and was credited with one official sack (effectively in on two). Jalen Redmond had five pressures and split a sack with Tyrion Grimdokin. Dallas Turner and Ivan Pace each had a sack; Pace got his immediately upon Cashman leaving the game. Van Ginkel and Dallas Turner each posted a 17.4% pass rush win rate; Ivan Pace posted 33%.

James Cook was held to 107 yards on 31 carries — 3.5 yards per attempt, −1.2 EPA per carry (40th percentile), 25% success rate (19th percentile). The yardage came in infrequent chunks and was not a sustainable threat. Ray Davis had two carries; Ty Johnson had one, which went for −0.9 EPA.

Byron Murphy's interception was highlighted at length. With two defenders already on Josh Allen's target, Murphy peeled off his assignment to gamble on the pick, took a moment to decide whether to try to return it, and ran it back over 100 yards — the second-longest play from scrimmage in the season to that point, by total yards the ball travelled. If the fumble Van Ginkel nearly forced (the ball was touching the shin as it came out) had been recovered, the Vikings might have won.

The offence, left to its own devices, scored six points. It had multiple drives with excellent field position and went approximately zero-for-eight on third down. The running game was working; it was not used. A screen pass thrown backwards was incomplete and briefly a live-ball scare. James: "This was a Vikings offence depending on the defence to score points." The Bills' time of possession was the third longest any team had sustained against the Vikings in 50 years — and the defence still held them to 23 points.

Quarterback Trade Speculation

[edit]

The Chargers (1-8) were still apparently convinced they could make the playoffs and were declining to trade anyone. The Raiders were unlikely to move Kirk Cousins — who had just had a three-interception game but prior to that was eighth in the NFL in EPA per play — given they had a highly drafted young quarterback behind him (quarterbacks drafted in the top five almost always play in year one, Arif noted). Vegas was at under 1% trade probability in Arif's view.

Arif's ranked trade targets:

  1. Geno Smith (Jets) — his top choice; the Jets were reluctant to trade Breece Hall, Garrett Wilson, and Braylon Allen for roster-continuity reasons, but those reasons did not apply to Geno.
  2. Jimmy Garoppolo (free agent) — probably cooked, probably too handsome to play football.
  3. Mac Jones (49ers) — San Francisco had reportedly wanted a second-round pick and change in the offseason; that price had gone up mid-season; Arif found himself reluctantly curious if the price was right, and hated that this was where things stood.

Funniest outcomes with over 1% probability: the Raiders do trade Cousins (Arif said under 1%, acknowledged he might be wrong); Seattle gets fed up with Sam Darnold, starts Drew Lock, trades Darnold back — but it won't be 2024 Darnold. Russell Wilson had just interviewed for the NC State head coaching job. Josh Johnson had been signed somewhere. "We've entered the Josh Johnson zone."

Mailbag

[edit]

James described this mailbag as not particularly long, partly because there wasn't much more to say about the game, and partly because there was clearly no choice but to end this episode.

Ben
Is Vikings fandom karmic justice for crimes in our earlier lives?
We're in the bad place.
Gordon (Yearning for Understanding Corner)
Was Kevin O'Connell recruited by the CIA in 2024 to be an asset in the administration's campaign to chastise Minnesota?
Arif: Wrong three-letter agency. KOC's father had a long career as a supervisory special agent in the FBI. Kevin O'Connell is an FBI asset to chastise Minnesota.
JN
Can Brian Flores win Coach of the Year? Has any coordinator ever been more deserving?
Arif looked up historical winners. 2015 Broncos defence: Ron Rivera of the Panthers won that year. Jason Garrett won once. Matt Nagy in 2018. KOC in 2024. The award typically follows the dominant side of the ball, and if that's the head coach's area, they get it. The PFWA award is not a dropdown menu — you write in whoever you want. Enough people organised, it could happen.
A Second Jet Has Hit Drew Bledsoe (Raged Defence Corner)
Are the Dolphins just as good at holding the Lions to sub-20 points?
Arif had tweeted the four dragons meme earlier — three impressive NFC North dragons (Jordan Love, Jared Goff, Caleb Williams) and Kevin, the fourth dragon who looks like an idiot, representing the Vikings' quarterback situation — in the first quarter, before Caleb Williams threw the first of his four interceptions. It went mini-viral. People in the replies noted that Jared Goff just threw picks against the Dolphins. Arif: Goff is sixth in EPA. You would kill for him. If people want to retroactively upgrade the Dolphins defence to cope, he wasn't going to stop them.
Sam Darnit (Worst Play of the Night Corner)
Which play tonight got Joe Buck and Troy Aikman to start laughing for the first time all season? Given this healing power — could Wentz resolve international disputes and become the next president?
"Mark down in your calendar. November 9th, 2026. That was the day Carson Wentz became president." James agreed this had to be the episode title. Arif added: Joe Biden had recently said he thought Donald Trump could have been a friend in another life. Don't say that. But if you need someone to unite Biden and Trump, Carson Wentz playing bad football in front of both of them would do it.
Siltown
Who is less deserving of their success, Kevin O'Connell or Chuck Schumer?
Arif: Schumer, because when KOC had 60 votes he at least got to the playoffs.
Skimbleshanks
Is Arif happy the whole Vikings fanbase finally shares his hatred of Carson Wentz?
"I'm never happy." It's like when a fascist gets elected and you said I told you so — but the I told you so doesn't feel good.
Skimbleshanks (also)
Rank these former Viking starting quarterbacks (all under 40) by how much you'd want to acquire them: JJ McCarthy, Sam Darnold, Joshua Dobbs, Nick Mullins, Geron Hall, Sean Mannion, Case Keenum, Sam Bradford, Teddy Bridgewater, Christian Ponder, Josh Freeman, Joe Webb.
Arif noted Kirk Cousins (38, one month and a week older than Arif) was not on the list. His ranking:
  1. Sam Darnold
  2. Teddy Bridgewater (hasn't played in a couple of years, but it's Teddy)
  3. JJ McCarthy (his recent game was reasonably bad rather than catastrophically bad, which is an upgrade)
  4. Case Keenum (playing recently is a benefit, even if it was bad)
  5. Nick Mullins (at least he'll actually throw the ball)
  6. Sam Bradford (best quarterback of the remaining names)
  7. Joe Webb (didn't know he was under 40; still probably the best athlete in the NFL; run the read option exclusively; you'd be wasting Jefferson, he didn't care, it's an offence)
  8. Joshua Dobbs (respect to the past)
  9. Christian Ponder (didn't expect to rank him ninth of twelve)
  10. Sean Mannion (technically a coach now; possibly an argument for seventh; not a good backup)
  11. Geron Hall (the worst EPA game in Vikings history)
  12. Josh Freeman (better than Hall numerically, but the vibes — the performance and what he gave off inside the Vikings facility — were catastrophic; spiritually last)
Professor Poop (Poopiness Scale Corner)
Rate Carson Wentz's performance on a 0–10 poopiness scale.
Arif's roommate recently had to unclog a drain. The reaction to what was unearthed was near-hospitalisation level. He was ready to start the car. Nine or ten.
Joey Meadstick (Freaky Friday Wednesday Corner)
What would it take to magically combine the best attributes of Carson Wentz and Kyler Murray into one quarterback? Would the resulting player still suck?
Arif: Wentz's height plus Murray's decision-making and accuracy is probably a playoff quarterback, notwithstanding the body breaking down and the loss of scrambling ability. They are so dimensionally apart in what they want to do that it's an awkward fusion. James: "There is no way this defence is playing meaningful games in January." Arif: "The defence needs to split into three. Offence, defence, special teams." James was confident special teams would join the defence's federation. Arif suggested Blake Cashman taking snaps from centre.
Mad Max Brosmer (Bullying and Cool Crime Corner)
Arif has been caught bullying a trans woman on a hot mic. Does he accept cancellation, or will he claim this is also a cool crime?
Arif: He bullies all of his friends. He happens to be friends with at least one trans woman, who came onto the podcast and was bullied accordingly because that is what he does to all podcast guests. Bullying trans women is not technically a crime in the current legal environment. It is also not a cool thing to do, so even if it were a crime, it would not be a cool one.
Anonymous (Insurance Claims Corner)
Someone dented their car with a car door and didn't leave a note. The submitter knows who it was. Confront them directly or call the cops?
James: The key to a good marriage is communication, and sometimes you have to do that through an intermediary like the law. (The person who dented the car was the submitter's wife.)
Room Temperature (Medical Corner)
Who would be in more pain throwing a football — JJ McCarthy or James?
James noted that he had spent the previous week in significant pain from an exercise injury, but he had never made a face like JJ McCarthy did on the sideline — a reaction so total that McCarthy "collapsed like a bunch of broccoli" and fell the hell over. Then McCarthy went back into the game.
And Taylor Joy (Petty Parenting Corner)
Daughter was a nightmare at her first D1 football game and they left after the first quarter. How to get revenge?
James: File it away. When the future wedding comes, make the entire day — before, during, and after — entirely about you. Twenty-five years of petty preparation.
Arif: Identify an activity she grows to love, preferably in live performance — theater, musicals. Invest in it deeply. And then, when the next Hamilton-calibre show is in peak run, acquire Broadway tickets and be the worst audience member in the history of Broadway — alarms every three minutes, heckling actors delivering objectively difficult and extraordinary performances — until you are both permanently banned from all Broadway theaters forever. James's addition: alarms, not phone calls. Arif acknowledged the collateral damage but noted that international relations had spent three years demonstrating that the doctrine of disproportionate response was the appropriate one.
Optimism Castle Doctrine Corner
If the final season keeps becoming an exercise in explaining fringe lore, has Norse Code turned into the Silmarillion?
(James ultimately pronounced it correctly, attributing it entirely to luck from a day of public address announcing.) Arif: If Norse Code's accumulated lore achieves a status so hallowed that a Tolkien-equivalent mythology is required to document it, that is fundamentally a sign of rot in our society. He would not be comfortable with what it said about us as a people. But yeah. Kind of cool.

Closing

[edit]

Arif was writing a Wide Left piece about the game — technically about the game, the nature of which would be clear when published. A post-trade-deadline mock draft was coming. All Ball would have a pseudo-live trade deadline reaction episode. And Arif confirmed he would be a daily guest contributor to the Better Offline podcast's CES coverage in January, alongside guests including Brennan Lee Mulligan — a prospect he described as awesome or terrifying.

James expressed deep jealousy at Arif's upcoming proximity to Brennan Lee Mulligan, specifically on account of the Roseate Spoonbill incident, and specifically the line "I knew it was a spoonbill" — which he described as the most underrated moment in game show history.

The episode closed: "All things are possible through the power of Ben DiNucci."