Jump to content

Episode 623

From NorseCode Wiki
Revision as of 01:15, 19 November 2026 by 172.18.0.1 (talk) (Create Episode 623: Weaponized Incompetence)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Episode 623

Weaponized Incompetence

Hosts Arif Hasan, James Pogatshnik
Guests None
Type Recap

Norse Code Episode 623: Weaponized Incompetence was a game-recap episode following the Vikings' first loss of the 2026 season, a 19-point defeat at the hands of the Detroit Lions. The episode opened with a cold open about an onslaught of Texas governor-race fundraising emails arriving in James's inbox despite him being unable to vote in Texas, then moved into an extended offensive post-mortem centring on Kyler Murray's performance — characterised by Arif as the football equivalent of a dad setting the cereal on fire while his wife is away for the weekend, with the defence left to handle everything. The main analytical body included a "Arif Debates Arif" segment presenting four options for righting the offence, a mailbag with statistical analysis of historically bad offences that turned around mid-season, a deeply alarming deep dive on Caleb Banks's rookie metrics, NFC playoff projections, and a defence of why the Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader-was-right trend was the worst take in recent cultural memory.

Overview

[edit]

Cold Open: Texas Election Emails

[edit]

James opened by noting that nothing motivates one to donate to a political campaign quite like receiving nine fundraising emails in 25 hours from a candidate — particularly when that candidate is running in Texas and James cannot vote there. The Democratic candidate for governor of Texas had apparently identified James as a potential donor and subjected him to a continuous email campaign throughout show prep. James described checking his deleted items and "just starting to count." The cold open drifted into a discussion of the Texas election ads that had been appearing during football, Arif's habit of occasionally ordering Bucky's products from Amazon ("Not outfits," James clarified — "the beaver nuggets and the candied almond thing"), and James's concern that campaign fundraising was diverting money that rightly belonged to Bucky's.

Announcements

[edit]

James noted that the Vikings had lost and there were no longer any undefeated teams in the NFL. He plugged Patreon (patreon.com/NorseCode, $3.50/month), PayPal (paypal.me/NorseCode), and the Threadless store (norsecode.threadless.com), where the Riefmas shower curtain and other seasonal merchandise were available. He reiterated the Boston live show: December 8th, 7:30 PM, at the 730 Tavern Kitchen and Patio in Cambridge, Massachusetts, with two tickets to the Vikings–Patriots Thursday night game that week being given away.

Vikings vs. Lions Game Recap

[edit]

The Vikings fell to the Lions for their first loss of the 2026 season, dropping to 6–1. The Lions were missing five starters by the end of the game — including Roldan, Jack Campbell, Brian Branch, and Kirby Joseph — which made the Vikings' offensive output all the more difficult to process.

Offensive Analysis

[edit]

Arif opened the recap with a framing device: the weaponized incompetence of the offence — the defence has held up everything, and the moment it looks away for even a moment, Kyler Murray is "pouring cereal and the cereal is on fire." The standard being held to the offence, Arif noted, was so low as to constitute a participation trophy, and the offence had not managed to clear it.

The offensive line was not Arif's primary concern. Murray was under pressure on only 27% of dropbacks — not exceptional volume — and his pressure-to-sack rate of 33% (one sack for every three pressures) was attributable primarily to Murray's pocket behaviour rather than the line. The Lions blitzed on 24% of plays; the pocket was not unusually muddy. Will Fryes and the line created problems, Arif allowed, but the story of the game was Murray.

The two plays that defined Arif's post-game frustration:

  1. The interception: A pick thrown to Justin Jefferson's side of the field, over Jefferson and to another receiver running a parallel out route five to seven yards away. Tom Brady, calling the game, was unable to determine whether it was a catastrophically inaccurate throw to Jefferson or a terrible decision to target someone else. Brady noted that if the intent was Jefferson, the execution was awful; if the intent was the other receiver, the decision was awful. "Your guess is as good as mine, Tom."
  1. The turn-down: Jefferson running a dig route over the middle, visibly open. Murray's helmet stripe is pointing directly at Jefferson. He brings the ball up — and then pulls it down and moves his eyes elsewhere. Jefferson, Arif noted, kills defences specifically on 19-yard dig routes over the middle. That is his entire essence of being. "If you're not hitting him when he's open there, you're never hitting him. The offence can't work. The offence is doomed forever."

Kurt Warner's analysis — that Murray has historically operated as a first-read-and-check-down quarterback with difficulty working through progressions — was raised and partially disputed: Arif noted that Murray had made correct second- and third-read decisions in earlier games this season, suggesting the problem was not purely structural. The more unusual element was his inaccuracy on plays he typically completes, including rollout play-action looks where the field was cut in half and the read was straightforward.

Arif produced a PFF heat map of Murray's throw distribution versus league average: entirely blue over the middle of the field, suggesting he was targeting that area far less than a typical quarterback. Much of the Kevin O'Connell offence is designed to attack the middle of the field — crossing routes to T.J. Hockenson, dig routes to Jefferson — which created a structural mismatch. Arif also noted the under-centre/shotgun tension: much of the play-action in the offence is designed to develop from under centre, and Murray, a shotgun quarterback, was seeing routes break too fast for the drops he was taking.

Justin Jefferson caught a touchdown — a contested circus catch — which Arif acknowledged was outstanding. It did not change the broader picture.

James described finding himself yelling at the television for the first time in years, specifically whenever four or more seconds elapsed with the ball in Murray's hands. Kirk Cousins was mentioned: Cousins had said publicly that week that in his current situation with the Giants, as with Jefferson before, you just have to trust the receiver and throw it in his direction even if he's covered. Arif: "If only you could have a quarterback who just throws it to Justin Jefferson. I don't know how that could have happened."

The fourth-and-short decision in field goal range was briefly analysed: ESPN's model recommended kicking; Ben Baldwin's fourth-down bot recommended going for it. Neither model rated it a toss-up. Arif found the disagreement interesting — it likely reflected either ESPN's model placing greater value on modern kicker accuracy or its accounting for the relative quality of the two teams (acknowledging the Vikings' offence as worse than the Lions' already-weak defence).

The Lions completed only three passes in the game — a feat not seen since the 1974 Bills — running for 310 yards from two backs instead. James noted that Victoria, a resident Bills fan in the Discord, tweeted: "We're not allowed to have anything."

Defensive Analysis

[edit]

Andrew Van Ginkle had 2.5 sacks and was involved in three of the four sacks the defence generated in the first half alone. Eric Wilson had the fourth sack, plus seven solo tackles, three tackles for loss, a quarterback hit, three additional stops, and two missed tackles. Blake Cashman played well. Tharon Jackson and James Pierre also had notable moments, with Pierre recording a pick.

Arif was not concerned about the run defence in spite of several big plays, noting that by EPA per play and success rate the Vikings were fifth in the league in stopping the run. Jamir Gibbs's near-breakaway run — where he escaped Isaiah Redmond's grasp and broke poor contain from Byron Murphy — felt worse than the numbers justified. The Vikings' blitz rate against the Lions was 90%, a figure Arif described as "psychotic" in the best sense. He noted that surrendering 19 points to a team averaging 31 was a genuinely good defensive performance, even accounting for 17 missed tackles across the game, most of them in the run game.

The defence was described, after opponent adjustment, as still number one in the league — and further ahead of its nearest competitor (the Seahawks, who had just had the doors blown off them) than at any prior point.

Theo Jackson left the game, resulting in Harrison Smith and Josh Metellus playing safety together for stretches, limiting the team's ability to run its preferred two-high looks. Arif noted he had briefly suggested acquiring a safety to push the defence from "extremely good" to "possibly historic" — a sentiment he stood by.

Arif Debates Arif

[edit]

James introduced the segment as Norse Code's occasional exercise in self-debate: Arif argues four positions on what the Vikings should do about their offence, with no advance knowledge of what the opposing options are.

Hope Kyler figures it out
The die has been cast. The Vikings are in open water. Kyler Murray has historically been a top-level quarterback — near-MVP, Pro Bowl, nearly All-Pro. We know what he can do. The accuracy problems are unusual relative to his history. The decision-making was closer in earlier weeks. These things are floating apart and when they come together, the offence will explode. The Vikings have bought time by going 6–1; now they spend it. 38% of historically bad offences have turned it around to reach even below-average output. This team has the talent for it.
Start Carson Wentz
Wentz has played this year as a spot starter with a truncated offence and been more productive than Murray by EPA per play, yards per attempt, and touchdown rate. Murray's one advantage — ball security — is partly an artefact of not throwing the ball. Murray does not throw over the middle; Wentz does. That's where Jefferson wins. The numbers with Wentz are twice Murray's touchdown rate against tougher defences. None of this matters. Start Carson Wentz.
Trade for a quarterback
The offence doesn't work. Who cares about the playbook? Do what they did with Joshua Dobbs — invent it on the sideline. The Vikings have been historically bad with starting quarterbacks and historically fine with backups; there's something to that. Kirk Cousins was briefly discussed as a name the Raiders would not trade. Gardner Minshew, Geno Smith, Marcus Mariota, anyone with a baseline ability to throw the ball four yards downfield. Dak Prescott was also explored — James had investigated the possibility — but the salary-cap mechanics made it prohibitive: a trade would accelerate all signing bonus and salary into the current year, creating a negative $84 million cap savings for the Cowboys ($128 million against the cap) on top of a $40 million current charge. A sign-and-trade structure could hypothetically work but would require multiple first-round picks. Arif: "Gardner Minshew can do that. Just get a guy."
Have Wes Phillips call plays
Kevin O'Connell has been coaching and play-calling simultaneously since his arrival. If the play-calling is not working, separate the roles. West Phillips has been learning to call plays for three to four years. Have him do it. O'Connell focuses on head-coach responsibilities — challenge flags, timeouts, game management, talking to the press. This is not "fire Kevin O'Connell into the sun," which James proposed as a fourth option before characterising it as cartoonish super-villainy rather than regular villainy.

Mailbag

[edit]

Kyler Murray Film Analysis (Andy)

[edit]

Andy asked whether the Kevin O'Connell system doesn't fit Murray's playstyle or whether Murray has simply regressed. Arif addressed the structural mismatch: the offence is built around throwing over the middle of the field, where Murray's throw distribution is well below league average. Play-action from under centre requires longer drops, which benefits taller quarterbacks who can throw over collapsing linemen; Murray at 5'10" has a physical disadvantage there. Much of what made the Kirk Cousins and Sam Darnold iterations of the offence work — standing in the pocket and throwing over the middle — doesn't translate to Murray's game. Separately, he has been unusually inaccurate on plays that have historically been strengths, including rollout play-action to the boundary. The cause of that accuracy decline is unclear.

Kyler's Utility Beyond Tight Spaces (Lurking)

[edit]

Lurking asked what Kyler Murray does, exactly, beyond squeezing into tight storage spaces to retrieve holiday decorations. Arif: "He scrambles." James: "Occasionally." Arif: "Every time he runs it looks like Stewie from Family Guy just scooting across."

Kevin O'Connell Trade Value (D's)

[edit]

D's asked what trade value O'Connell might have across the league. Arif: a first-round pick, possibly, given the difficulty of sourcing offensive head coaches with successful track records. Kenneth Allen appeared as an adjacent name in James's transcript note; it was left in.

What Makes a Quarterback Hesitant in a Clean Pocket? (Kenneth Allen)

[edit]

Kenneth Allen asked about the culprits for Murray's hesitation in relatively clean pockets, usually associated with younger quarterbacks struggling with reads. Arif's answer, after a long pause: "Everything. Throw the ball. I don't know."

Is the Offence the NFL's Theranos? (Beef Bruce G)

[edit]

Beef Bruce G asked whether Kevin O'Connell's offence was the NFL version of Theranos. Arif and James confirmed they had both watched the Theranos movie since it was first mentioned on the show. Their conclusion: "We cannot fix her." The analogy was extended: Kyler Murray is the Edison machine, with a theoretical 2.0 version out there that can execute all the functions the offence has been assigned to it — so long as it receives the right chemistries, which is plural for a reason James declined to explain.

Statistical Corner: Can This Offence Turn Around? (LeVar Bolshereef)

[edit]

LeVar Bolshereef asked, via the Parable / Fable / Allegorical / Arefable Corner, what historical offences had been this bad through eight weeks and turned it around.

Arif ran a filter for offences that were in the bottom tier (roughly 29th–32nd) across three metrics simultaneously — points per drive, EPA per play, and success rate — through the first eight weeks of a season. He found 42 such offences going back to 2006. Of these, 16 (38%) got substantially better, defined as rising to within half a standard deviation of the median — not to average, just to below-average.

Only five of the 16 that improved did so by changing quarterbacks. The other 11 stayed the course. Separately, 17 of the 42 total changed quarterbacks — and of those, 12 did not improve, suggesting a quarterback change was neither necessary nor sufficient. The examples of teams that improved without changing quarterbacks were more common than intuition suggested, including the 2005 Buccaneers (whose Brady-era turnaround took until Week 8 or 9 to materialise), the 2006 Ravens, the 2014 Eagles, and the 2018 Titans.

Arif's conclusion: 38% odds of a turnaround to below-average functionality felt higher than he expected. Given Murray's historical talent and the skill group around him, those odds were probably applicable here, and the bar — below-average, not average — was low enough that reaching it would likely be enough for this team to win games.

Olive Garden Parable Corner (LeVar Bolshereef, cont.)

[edit]

LeVar Bolshereef extended the question into an allegory: the Vikings are Arif at the Olive Garden — started off eating fraudulently (a small noodle dish standing in for the inferior opponents), won their internal competition through dubious means, felt uneasy, excused themselves to the bathroom. The question was what the Vikings' "underpaid single mom" equivalent would be — who cleans up their mess — and what skills they could borrow from Arif's performance to replicate it on the gridiron.

Arif clarified: he had genuine remorse for the Olive Garden staff. He did not have remorse for winning. He cheated, and he won. The playbook equivalent: throw the Angel hair pasta in the trash, get a normal pasta. A simple offence. Fettuccine. Ravioli. A couple of slants, a couple of quick-outs, one deep shot. Nothing wrapped too tightly around the fork.

Mitchell Trubisky Corner: Does Kyler Throw Left? (Decile)

[edit]

Decile, via the Reeves Mitchell-Trubisky Corner, asked whether Kyler's issues were directional — specifically whether he couldn't throw left, given that the interception and several incompletions went left. Arif: the difference from the Mitchell-Trubisky situation is that Trubisky didn't throw left and was bad when he did; Murray throws left more often than right relative to league average, so there are simply more bad throws to the left because most of his throws are bad and most go left. His first pick of the season — before his injury — was to the right.

QB Extension & Next Season's Starter (Damian Bolsharief)

[edit]

Damian Bolsharief asked who the Vikings' starting quarterback would be next season, given that Kyler Murray was not getting an extension. Arif reviewed the upcoming free-agent market: Deshaun Watson ("woof"), Aaron Rodgers (has promised to retire; James noted he also promised to be immunized), Jacobi Brissett ("that would be hilarious, actually"), Kirk Cousins (on a one-year void, so technically free), Justin Fields, Anthony Richardson, Davis Mills, Marcus Mariota, Joe Flacco, and Justin Herbert (via trade, with the note that "maybe mental health services in Minnesota are better than they are in California, which is possible"). The honest answer: draft one.

Can Wes Phillips Call Plays? (Optimism Castle Doctrine)

[edit]

Optimism Castle Doctrine asked how much worse Wes Phillips could be at calling plays. Arif: "Yes," to the implicit premise that it couldn't get worse — but also yes to the proposition that it could get worse and still not matter, because the fundamental problem is scoring. The recommendation was to get Wes in there and have him whisper sweet nothings in Kyler Murray's headset. James suggested resurrecting Wade Phillips or Bum Phillips. Arif: "I don't care."

Caleb Banks: How Worried? (Chandler)

[edit]

Chandler asked how worried to be about Caleb Banks's slow start. Arif ran an analysis of every first-round defensive tackle drafted between picks 13 and 23 since 2006, using PFF grades as a proxy for performance quality.

His findings:

  • Caleb Banks had the lowest PFF grade through seven games of any player in the sample at 26.7. It was not close. Kenneth Grant was next at 35.1.
  • Replacement level for a first-round pick in this analysis was approximately 60.0. Banks is 20.
  • The company he keeps: Corey Liuget (a bust), Kalani Vakameilalo (oof), Javon Kinlaw, Justin Harrell. The only possible exception was Shuri Floyd, who had a 56.0 grade and was then lost to injury.
  • Successes in the sample all graded 60 or above as rookies: Byron Murphy (60.7), Michael Brocker (63.3), Christian Wilkins (64.6), Daron Payne, Jeffrey Simmons (65+).
  • Banks's defensive on/off impact — how the defence performs when he's on the field vs. off the field — was the worst of any defensive tackle in the NFL. The Vikings are a noticeably worse defence when he's on the field. "You can't have one of history's greatest defences potentially have 15 snaps a game where they might be pretty easy to score on."

Arif concluded he was more concerned than he anticipated being going into the analysis. The historical record for players this far below the threshold in this pick range is poor.

Off the Rails: Canadian Football & Nick Demski (Nolan Kaler)

[edit]

Nolan Kaler referenced the Blue Bombers' remarkable CFL comeback in the Grey Cup semifinals, led by Nick Demski, and asked whether the Lions had drawn inspiration from it. Arif, noting that a member of a group chat he was in had refused to stop talking about the game: "It must have been pretty good." He doubted the Lions had consciously borrowed from it, but noted that the Vikings certainly had not and perhaps should have.

James noted that he and several friends were travelling to Winnipeg at the end of the month, and that Winnipeg — unlike most of Manitoba — does not observe daylight saving time, putting it one hour ahead rather than behind.

James's Passive-Aggressive Holiday Celebration Corner (Arif's Tormentor)

[edit]

Arif's Tormentor asked, via James of Grand Forks's Passive-Aggressive Holiday Celebration Corner, for a papal decree about when to wear Riefmas gear: specifically, could it begin on Thanksgiving given the 10-year anniversary shirt features a turkey motif?

James's answer: now is the time to acquire it; Thanksgiving is a reasonable start date for wearing it; Black Friday is the firm start of the Christmas season. The Riefmas shower curtain was available at norsecode.threadless.com and was described as an ideal way to introduce relatives to the tradition.

The question ended with a proposed honorific — "In the name of the Father, the Arif, and the Dusty Spirit" — which Arif acknowledged as a "pretty astounding end" to a question that had seemed to be going somewhere else entirely.

James's Republican Corner (A Second Jet Has Hit Drew Bledsoe)

[edit]

A Second Jet Has Hit Drew Bledsoe asked whether James would replace Arif with Hallie Stevens as co-host. James declined to have a sufficient opinion on Republican governance to answer substantively. Arif noted that Stevens had filmed her post-election video at a Dutch angle — "the Wikipedia entry for Dutch angle" — and suggested this was bad optics. James compared it to the original Thor movie's filming choices, then revealed his own first wedding photographs were shot at the same angle: "The gift of prophecy visited that camera person."

Should Goff Be an MVP Candidate? (Real Question Corner)

[edit]

An unnamed question from the Real Question Corner asked whether Jared Goff should be a legitimate MVP candidate and why he hadn't received national consideration, and also requested a name for the Vikings' defence.

On MVP: Arif said yes, Goff should be in the conversation, but noted the current top candidates were Brock Purdy, Josh Allen, Trae Young, and Trevor Lawrence, with Jared Goff rounding out the top six. He argued that if the award were given to the objectively best player in football, it would go to Amon-Ra St. Brown's positional equivalent — specifically Davante Adams, who was playing at a level so far ahead of number two that the gap dwarfed the gap between the best linebacker and the next-best. For the award as typically given, Goff was borderline. The reason he wasn't further up: Jameer Gibbs's presence made evaluators question how much of the offence Goff was responsible for.

On defence naming: the Purple Atlas entry — "they hold up the world, and everything goes bad if they shrug" — was acknowledged as excellent. Arif noted several names had been submitted via DM and would be surfaced when it made sense to revisit the topic; they had covered it in four consecutive episodes and were relaxing on it.

Arif's Debate Skills (Reef's Midlife Crisis)

[edit]

Reef's Midlife Crisis asked about Arif's minor critiques of Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed's debate technique. Arif gave an extended answer: El-Sayed was an outstanding communicator with excellent message discipline and a talent for reframing hostile questions around the values he wanted to discuss. The minor critique: a habit of asking rhetorical questions he knew the answer to ("Do you love your dad?"), which created impressive moments when the target was unskilled but could be neutralised by a more experienced interlocutor who declined to answer immediately — as happened in an interview with Ross Douthat, where El-Sayed's question-first framing briefly lost its momentum.

James noted that someone at the North Dakota Democratic Party had suggested James should consider running for office after learning he was a union leader living in Grand Forks with organisational experience. James laughed and walked away. "You don't know the skeletons."

Tolkien Canadian asked whether one could bet against Polymarket's existence on Kalshi. Arif: probably, that seems to be the whole thing with prediction markets.

NFC Playoff Picture (Everybody Else Is the Mailman)

[edit]

Everybody Else Is the Mailman asked who would make the NFC playoffs. Arif's model (based on ten offensive and defensive key stats, excluding special teams), as of Ep623:

Team Playoff %
San Francisco 49ers 96%
Minnesota Vikings 87%
Chicago Bears 81%
New York Giants 75%
Detroit Lions 71.9%
Green Bay Packers 58%
Seattle Seahawks 44%
Los Angeles Rams 42%
Tampa Bay Buccaneers 41.8%

Arif noted that the Bears' percentage did not yet account for the Jeffrey Simmons acquisition and was likely understated. No NFC South team was projected to make the playoffs. Arif described the Giants' presence as "someone is required by law to win the NFC East."

Arif's Romance Corner: First Date Crimes (Room Temperature)

[edit]

Room Temperature asked, via Arif's Romance Corner, what crime was best to commit for a great first date and — for James's Marriage Corner — what crime to wait for holy matrimony to commit together. James suggested grand larceny. Arif suggested activities that might attract ICE attention, stopping well short of martyrdom. Room Temperature's own suggestion for the marriage corner: rebroadcasting NFL games without the express written consent of the National Football League.

Media Literacy Corner: Worst Take (Francis Ford Copium)

[edit]

Francis Ford Copium asked, via Arif's Media Literacy Corner, whether the worse take was: (a) taking Starship Troopers literally, or (b) the Anakin Skywalker/Darth Vader-was-right position.

Arif argued at length that the Anakin take was worse. Starship Troopers is a satire of fascist aesthetics and propaganda, and while the irony requires a small degree of media literacy to perceive — the book, Arif noted, plays those same elements more seriously — it's widely understood as such. The Anakin take, by contrast, requires misreading a film where the villain: wears a black suit, has yellow evil eyes, is explicitly modelled by George Lucas on George W. Bush, says George W. Bush lines verbatim, commits ethnic cleansing on Tatooine, kills the younglings, loses his wife, and subsequently operates on a planet made of lava. "I don't know how else to like — it's so obvious what the movie is saying."

The trend, Arif explained, was an AI-generated Anakin-in-a-MAGA-hat meme push timed before the midterm elections, with the argument that the empire was right to consolidate power. The steelman version of this — involving the Yu Zhaan Vong extra-galactic invasion that Palpatine was supposedly preparing for — was addressed and dismissed: Imperial sources consistently say the invasion was a surprise; the consolidation of military resources into Death Stars left no capacity to respond to it; the whole thing is "so stupid." Arif: "Do you think you're going to win the midterms by saying you're on the side of Darth Vader?"

The segment also touched on a "Malphood" trend Arif declined to describe, except to note it involved gender-bending Draco Malfoy and had been briefly popular just before the Anakin cycle replaced it.

Closing

[edit]

James expressed that the episode had taken either a year off Arif's life or a year off his remaining sanity. Arif invoked the Law of Equivalent Exchange from Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood: everyone was losing a year. The next episode was announced as a Bills preview.

Arif plugged Wide Left Football, noting upcoming pieces: his own piece on the fickle nature of hopelessness; Luke's piece on the play-calling (described as "significantly different" from his piece of a few weeks prior); Matt Freese's piece on the run defence; and James Foster's college notebook. He also mentioned his All Ball podcast (The Defector) and a forthcoming piece with The Guardian.